DeflateGate: The Smoking Gun

THE CROOKED CASE AGAINST TOM BRADY: WHAT’S WRONG WITH THIS PICTURE?

The NFL insists that science alone cannot explain the Patriots’ pressure drop.

Therefore the ball attendant must have deflated them — and quarterback Tom Brady must have known.Gauges

Much depends on which gauge the referee actually used to measure the balls pre-game. The referee remembers using his longer-needled (LOGO) gauge.  But the “independent” investigator/consultants rejected the referee’s recollection.

Do the gauges resemble each other so much that the referee would mis-remember which he used?

gauges2

 

THE SMOKING GUN

How much longer exactly is the longer needle?  See for yourself.   Examine the independent consultant’s own close-up: What do the rulers tell your eyes?

Look again.  (Yes, they shifted one ruler .2” to deflate the difference!)  The longer, LOGO gauge needle really measures TWICE AS LONG as the shorter one.

Would an experienced referee who used one of these gauges 24 times that day, mistake it for the other?

But wait!  There’s another trick in this optical illusion:  Are the needles both “slightly bent” as Exponent’s caption suggests?

Or did the “independent” investigator/consultants earn their millions by shooting a photograph specifically to eliminate the greater bend of the longer needle?  This further deflates the difference.  Look carefully.  The truth lurks in the shadow.

How could these sophisticated scientific/engineering PhD statisticians with all their complex simulations and graphs somehow misalign two simple rulers?  Accident — or con job?

Once you credit the referee’s memory here, and reject one other pseudo-scientific piece of twisted logic, science can fully explain the entire pressure drop.

Leaked mis-information, implausible assumptions and daring distortions obscure the truth.

Deflategate is a sham — an NFL cooked-up fraud.  So who cheated:  The quarterback or the League?

29 thoughts on “DeflateGate: The Smoking Gun

    • Thanks and other bloggers such as Robert Young are finding more hidden tricks. Really disgraceful, but the truth will out.

  1. Nice pick up on your end. I have considered the differences and conclude Andersen would have remembered which gauge he used. Consider this. Here is a question I have on the Wells report and investigation. I have read the report
    numerous times. I am in the aerospace business and have been involved in many failure analysis where every bit of evidence is crucial to determining the fault. Based on the Wells report and the appeal transcripts I can’t understand why the intercepted ball was not given more review. This is the only piece of evidence that the NFL had ( and still does) that was not contaminated by the halftime fiasco and subsequent inflation of the other 11 balls. The Wells report said that ball was measured on the sideline by the Colts with a pressure gauge and then brought into the locker room and was measured 3 times by the NFL using the Patriots gauge. All 3 readings were above the Exponent calculated minimum per the Ideal gas law of 11.32 psi. When questioned about this ball during the appeal, Wells contradicted his own report and indicated there was 2 gauges used and the data from this ball was not used in any of the statistical analysis because there was a question as to if the Colts may have deflated it. This makes no sense. Since the critical point is what gauge did Walt Andersen use pre-game then why didn’t anyone think to stick the Logo gauge into that ball when it was back to it’s equilibrium state. This ball according to the Wells report was handed over to Wells from Weiss for the investigation. My bet is that it was gauged and read about 12.5 psi. The shell game with this ball and the vague explanations about it make me very suspicious. Why didn’t this happen? Could it be that Wells hid this information knowing he had a 3 Mil payday in front of him and knew exonerating the Patriots at that point would end the investigation? I have not read anything about this. Am I missing something? Your thoughts?

    • Good point. See ELGEE at backpicks blog. He extracts a similar usefulness from the intercepted ball.

      Often when Wells report discounts evidence it’s probably because its not useful. What happened to the Colts gauge and Patriots gauge. Conveniently lost. What attempt to find them?

      Intercepted ball’s three separate measurements used as evidence that a particular gauge can vary.

  2. Thanks for pointing this out. Although I’ve read through numerous documents relating to this “controversy,” the appendix section of the Wells Report made my eyes glaze over, and I’m sure I’m not the only one who easily missed this or skipped over it. Surely, Dr. Marlow couldn’t claim this exhibit as being “A+ kind of work.”

    • Isn’t that the truth. I picked this up only on the fourth reading, and I was scouring the Exponent appendix to find the basis for their support of the sequence. Could find none — all probability counts against them. The patriots balls were measured, then reinflated, then 4 Colts balls measured.

      It’s so much easier to bury stuff in an appendix.

      • Wrong. Read the report again. The Patriots’ balls were not reinflated until after the Colts balls had been tested. You are inserting assumptions to try to discredit experts who are trained in these things. Exponent made assumptions about the data, and then went back and checked to see what it would look like if they ‘undid’ their assumptions (The Colt’s 3rd ball anomaly). I don’t know what your bias is in this whole thing, but I am certainly glad you are a lawyer and not a forensic engineer . . . you would not be a very good one. Engineers have to state and justify their assumptions, yours would not pass that justification part.

  3. You don’t use a ruler to measure bend. You use a ruler to measure length. You would hold the ruler to match the angle of the needle to get the most accurate measurement of length.
    The fact that the gauges look nothing alike is interesting to find out but don’t add bad info to try and make it more than it is.

    • You missed my point. Perhaps I didn’t explain it clearly. Exponent photographed the longer needle (LOGO) gauge to diminish the angle, not because it makes it longer, but because it makes it less distinguishable from the other gauge, thus lending false credibility to the caption below figure three that both needles were “slightly bent”.

  4. The NFL “case” against Tom Brady is an attempt at reputational lynching.This story transcends the NFL and sport generally, going to the heart of how the arrogance of power in our culture, in big and little ways, has become increasingly more ruthless because it believes it’s not only not going to be held accountable to fact and ethical values–but also because it believes it can manipulate both the mechanisms of accountability and what people value through the most invidious kind of Orwellian diktat.

    The under-the-radar effort to fleece nearly $2 million dollars from Brady, with no compelling evidence of wrongdoing, should be exposed for what it is: theft.

      • It’s the character assassination of a decent and INNOCENT man- something that will now ALWAYS be attached to his name- due to the vast majority of people, it seems unfortunately, that refuse to believe otherwise, and have absolutely no interest in hearing the truth. There are different opinions on how active his “involvement” allegedly was- but there are few, more than 20 miles out of Boston, that don’t believe he was a part of this circus side show- thus labeling him a “cheater”.

        THAT is the travesty and disgrace of what Roger Goodell and the NFL has done to him and the entire Patriots organization with this conjured up fiasco!

  5. 1.
    Many great men remind us,
    We can make our lives sublime.
    When we depart, what will we leave behind?
    It should be more than footprints in the sands of time.

    2. Make honest citizen is better more than a barbarous politician

    3. Distort justice is national traitor

    4. Capitalism will be bankrupted by the distrust

    5. Justice is the great sublime that is highest expressed dignity by the United States Constitution

    6. Perform Justice, which is peaceful, but anti-justice as demagogy

    7. Justice is long lasting, but power has a short life.

    8. Constitution is protection for all people,
    But it’s not cheating for weak men

    9. Book is a master key opening the humanity treasure

    10. Human life is short and bitter,
    And therefore, it ought to fight for human dignity

    11. The grass-tree aims to the sun,
    So human person must be moral truth

    12. If you always live with men who are warlike,
    You’ll be become a barbarous man

    13 The string of love is volunteered dedication to each other without compulsion

    14. A sublime life of a person is moral and great ability

    15. Self struggle is seeking for the justice

    16. Happiness of humankind is not luxurious matters,
    but human dignity is great more than everything in human life

    17. Our world will not have peace
    Because the blood and flesh fly always takes place
    When the forgiveness is very low,
    The animosity is without limitlessness

    18. If the superior does not have conduct himself properly
    His inferiors would make a riot

    19. Put into effect faithfully laws, society is peaceful

    20. The Justice of the powerful is not belonged to the weak and the poor

    21. The voices of the weak people are patriotic

    22. Democracy of the powerful is not truthful

    23. There is not had sublime justice by its distrust

    24. Rather see is good than hear.

    25. Fight for a legal’s revolution that our worldwide is peaceful.

    26. Holy light of heart symbolizes for faithful love

    27. The great hope of America society is individual character.
    Therefore, my life is not to be a brick, which lies under dirty mud.
    Instead, I see my life as a brick, which supports the building of the
    American democracy.

    28. All of the political parties of the world should be died by their lies

    29. Super government of a nation is robbery
    That who has more modern weapons
    When its honest people are unarmed hands

    30. Wisdom must be won the injustice power

    31. Circle of injustice-society
    Grandfather of racism is slave
    it gave a birth to injustice
    Father of injustice is inequality
    it was born to injustice power

    32. Put into effect faithfully laws, society is peaceful

    33. We, the American people, can question ourselves
    That why did our nation not win any wars
    From decade 60 to up-to-day,
    But we still fall in love with the wars?

    34. A good heart is of valued more than the biggest skyscraper.

    35. A small, stiff tree breaks more than a flexible one.

    36. The morality treasure of a sublime leader is lost by its inequality
    Then his dignity will be faded by human history

    37. Enslave exists, so the inequality increases up

    38. War looks like a hole.
    It buries many people.
    All of them lack paddies,
    yet, the bombs crumble their bodies

    39. If you wished to be a sublime man,
    You should understand the rules of the society and here are:

    Three main paths are:
    The Happiness,
    The Source of Life
    and the Sorrow.
    And with Noble fivefold are:
    The Right Thoughtfulness,
    The Right Love,
    The Right forgiveness,
    The Right Struggles
    and the Right Independence,

    40. A best of American citizen is paying full income taxes, voting for elections, and not violating to any American laws,
    But the American courts prohibit sharing any American justices,

    41. We communicate morality to our children
    Our morality does not only make them happiness
    But also builds their lives perfect
    So our morality is to be noble more than gold and money

    42. A pious child must adore parents, siblings and relations
    That child also respects teachers, adults and laws

    43. His books communicate his ideologies to human beings
    These look like rose-petals throwing down the Grand Canyon
    His books are of immortalized lamp of the wise accumulation
    He’ll wait for his offspring who will be hearing the echoes

    44. I only tremble to from my poor intelligence,
    But never tremble from my poor life

    45. An honest book is valued more than a barbarous leader

    46. A good name is liked the perfume of the nature,
    So, a bad name of barbarous leader will be insulted by his history

    47. I thought, ‘A person liked to brawl with everybody,
    So he lost the wisdom of life

    48. A slight light shone at the end of the dark tunnel
    And I do hope it’d shine on my path.

    49. We are one’s self of super enemy
    If we were coward of friendships
    But we are courageous men,
    We’ll be best friendship of each other

    50. Truth would only be understood.
    It’d not be described
    And it could not be explained
    Truth should only be stayed in heart.

    51. The choice of justice is rather than violence
    That it is the reason of sublime man of wisdom
    When the ones have dropped off justice,
    They’ve tremendous shock in their wisdom.

    52. Thoughts shows you that you’ve dreams
    To make an idea as you’d have it be
    And that because you wish them
    You dream them as while you see it.

    52. Each individual has an own place to build dream in the world, is important in some respect and whether she or he chooses to be so or not. Therefore, my money, ever since, is not the end of life, but my character is important more than the matters.

    53. Duty of child is first pious
    The child respects its parents
    He always obeys to his parents
    As their experiences are sublime than him

    54. A powerful government could never protect to its people,
    But it must first protect its interests of essence of life.

    55. Education is of understanding,
    Had understood must do correctly.
    If you had educated excellently, but did wrongly
    You are not human being.

    56. The great end of my life is not money,
    But this is my own knowledge.

    57. A wonderful painting is an historical book of present’s civilization time,

    58. Love is the birds
    That laughs in the sky
    If a person has not love –
    A car, broken down

    59. Those were rebellious ministers, generals and heroes
    The Justice cause was lost people, homeland and justice.

    60. Let me than be up and struggling
    For the Holy fire of human rights, shinning
    With my heart for any fate
    If not to achieve, I must pursue

    61. If someone ruined his house, he’d not avenge him
    Because it is of low intelligence

    62. He takes up his torch in the darkness.
    When we travel the long road
    His torch is not snuffed out by the wind.
    It burns bright in the rainstorm, his flame

  6. That photo is deceptive but representative of this entire debacle, from the sting-like approach taken by league executives and the head official on game day (all shirking their duties and/or deviating from accepted practice) to the blatant bumbles, miscues, invalid and unsupported assumptions in the Wells investogation.

  7. There’s other variables at play too. The Wells Report doesn’t actually state the effect of wetness on ball pressure, it only infers it within graphs. The graphs state that its around 0.2 but you can’t be sure as the graphs are quite vague. SmartLabs analysis months ago showed that it was up to 0.7 psi effect.

    There’s another factor too. Wells report states that 2 balls failed inspection and were reinflated. What if those balls used the lower gauge?!? If you look at the Prioleau numbers, there is clearly 2 balls that are noticably lower than the others.

  8. Why did no one ever consider the gauges were switched pre-game after inflating the Patriots ball? They were definitely switched at halftime, we all know that and assuming Patriots logo vs Colts non logo pre-game would explain every 1/100th of a psi of difference

  9. If you really think that Exponent purposefully turned the needle to obscure the bend in the longer needle in the photo on page 175, then why in the world would they clearly show the larger bend in Figure 2 and Figure 4 directly above and below, respectively, the photo that you are choosing to focus on? Seems like you try to imply that they are really sly in trying to slant their evidence, but then make a middle-schooler’s mistake in showing in the photos above and below what you claim they were trying to cleverly hide in the middle photo. Instead, I think it is you who is trying to make a big issue about something that is, in fact, absolutely nothing.

  10. Was there ever a test between the two gauges to identify the difference in calibration between the two? I would assume that by manufacturer’s specification the gauges are calibrated when leaving the factory (not to say that they could lose calibration with use). Does the needle length really matter if the error of the measurement isn’t significant? Even if you can’t remember, you could fairly easily compare the combination of using each gauge to determine whether the differences in error (or lack thereof) correspond to the differences in the deflated footballs couldn’t you?

  11. Also, it looks as if the longer needle was screwed tightly into its housing while the shorter one appears to be a turn or so unscrewed. (If you looks closely, you can see one or one-and-a-half threadings exposed at the short needle’s base…and none at the long needle’s base.) That seems inconsequential on its own. But when combined with the ruler-shifting and the manipulation of the angles at which the needles were photographed, it certainly seems as if Exponent was trying to fudge some visual support for their finding that Mr. Anderson’s “misremembered” which gauge he used pregame. I always thought it odd that Exponent and the NFL accepted verbatim Mr. Anderson’s unaided recall of the exact pregme pressures, within a tenth of a PSI, of 24 separate footballs, but then rejected his recall of the one gauge he used to record those pressures. (Exponent’s explanation basically boils down to: It would have been easy for Anderson to be wrong about which gauge he used pregame because the gauges were so similar in appearance. 2. We only have measurements for 4 of the 12 Colt balls, and we discount one of those measurements because it would mess up our calculations. (Also, shhhhh….we measured the Colt balls after they had been sitting and warming up in a 72-74 degree locker room for 15 minutes, but we won’t account for that in our calculations) 3. But, if Anderson were not wrong about the pregame gauge, our data doesn’t support our hypothesis. 4. Therefore, Anderson was wrong about the one pregame gauge. But precisely right about the 24 pregame pressure measurements.

  12. This has been bothering me for a long time as a Patriots fan and really believe Brady was not the culprit in this case. Nice investigating, Robert and just another fact leading to the sham of the NFL bias. Everyone knows that Goodell and his henchmen are NY oriented with ties to NY Jets….uummmm….talk about bias…..And one very important aspect to the comment “Generally Aware”….If they thought Brady was generally aware the footballs were low on pressure….wouldn’t the referres, who handle those footballs more than anyone else in the game, also be “generally aware” and change balls…This whole process was a sham to begin with against the entire organization, not entirely against Brady. As I write this, the NFL is still planning on pursuing this case and the appeal. Unbelievable….When its all said and done, Brady should sue the NFL, for deformation of character, slander, discrimination, obstructing justice, tampering with evidence…did I miss anything?

  13. There is something else fraudulent in the photos. Note the size of the rulers. The one at the bottom is noticeably smaller. That indicates that the photo was shrunken slightly…just enough so it would go unnoticed. If you bring it up in size so that the rulers are equal, the larger needle is even more markedly distinguishable.

  14. In support of your thesis there is an additional obvious bias indicator. Look at the rulers. The ruler in the photo for the larger needle is smaller than the ruler in the photo for the smaller needle. This could only happen if it was zoomed in more. This approach makes the larger needle look smaller.

  15. A sham! That’s what “Deflategate” is. And as this is 4 months down the road now, it’s clearly known that the NFL/Goodell lied AGAIN in a court of law.
    The NFL said that they would be testing footballs during games this year…Then the NFL said they’d do “random” testing!

    Has anyone seen or heard about any of these results. Don’t worry you won’t, because the PSI testing favors New England, so the NFL will NEVER release those PSI stats.

    Happy Holidays all.

  16. Very well written!
    I will immediately seize your rss feed as I can not to find your
    e-mail subscription link or newsletter service.
    Do you’ve any? Kindly allow me know in order that I may just subscribe.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Robert Blecker Captcha * Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.